Fireplace & Stove Shopping Guide (In-Depth)

---

Older models typically lack modern EPA compliance and burn less cleanly, producing more smoke and creosote. New certified stoves are safer, more efficient, and reduce chimney maintenance.

Evaluate igniters, burners or elements, blowers, and control boards. If multiple components are failing or parts are obsolete, replacement can be more reliable than repair.

Non-catalytic units generally must be rated at <= 2.5 g/hr particulate emissions. Always verify current local and state requirements before purchase and installation.

Uncertified appliances are typically inefficient and higher-polluting. Upgrading improves air quality, safety, and may qualify you for incentives.

These options offer easier start-up, thermostatic control, and less daily maintenance than cordwood. Pellet availability and gas line capacity should be checked in advance.

Many newer models have smaller footprints and different clearance-to-combustible requirements. Verify hearth protection size, mantel clearances, and the required venting system or liner.

Inserts and direct-vent appliances often need a stainless steel liner or coaxial vent sized to the appliance. Proper lining improves draft, safety, and manufacturer warranty compliance.

Use a heat-loss estimate that considers square footage, insulation, windows, and climate. Oversizing causes short cycling and discomfort; right-sizing improves comfort and fuel use.

A wide turndown ratio prevents overheating on mild days and allows steady, comfortable heat. Look for multiple heat settings, thermostatic control, or modulating burners.

Some counties prohibit burning on poor air-quality days unless you use an EPA-certified device. Check local air agency alerts and rules each heating season.

If blowers, door gaskets, glass, or controls are degraded and hard to source, a new unit can be safer and more economical. Consider total cost of parts, labor, and downtime versus replacement benefits.